Featured Pencils

Set Descending Direction
Page
  1. Dental Pencil Sampler Dental Pencil Sampler
    #PDNT
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  2. Butterfly Sparkle Pencils Butterfly Sparkle Pencils
    #PCL348
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  3. Sparkle Flower Pencils Sparkle Flower Pencils
    #PCL259
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  4. Ladybug Pencils Ladybug Pencils
    #PCL271
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each

    OUT OF STOCK
  5. Halloween Pencil Sampler Halloween Pencil Sampler
    #HPNL
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  6. Assorted Eyeballs Pencils Assorted Eyeballs Pencils
    #PCL670
    $13.99

    48 for $13.99

    Only 29¢ each


  7. SmileMakers Pencil Sampler SmileMakers Pencil Sampler
    #PSAM
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  8. Christmas Pencil Sampler Christmas Pencil Sampler
    #CHPL
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  9. Peanuts® Christmas Pencils Peanuts® Christmas Pencils
    #PCL613
    $13.99

    48 for $13.99

    Only 29¢ each


  10. Character Pencil Sampler Character Pencil Sampler
    #PLIC
    $83.99

    250 for $83.99

    Only 34¢ each


  11. Dental Pencil & Eraser Sampler Dental Pencil & Eraser Sampler
    #DNER
    $73.99

    400 for $73.99

    Only 18¢ each


  12. SmileMakers Groovy Pencil Sampler SmileMakers Groovy Pencil Sampler
    #PGRV
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  13. Hockey Pencils Hockey Pencils
    #PCL139
    $13.99

    24 for $13.99

    Only 58¢ each


  14. Thermo Happy Birthday Pencils Thermo Happy Birthday Pencils
    #PCL609
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each

    OUT OF STOCK
  15. Animal Pencil Sampler Animal Pencil Sampler
    #PANM
    $62.99

    250 for $62.99

    Only 25¢ each


  16. Custom Regular and Neon Pencils Custom Regular and Neon Pencils
    #CUS855
    As low as $46.99

    144 for $46.99

    Only 33¢ each

  17. Camo Pencils Camo Pencils
    #PCL392
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  18. Brush Floss Smile Pencils Brush Floss Smile Pencils
    #PCL174
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  19. Zoo Animal Pencils Zoo Animal Pencils
    #PCL597
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  20. Fuzzy Animal Pencils Fuzzy Animal Pencils
    #PCL314
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  21. What Do You See Pencils What Do You See Pencils
    #PCL692
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  22. Chatter Box Pencils Chatter Box Pencils
    #PCL691
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  23. Smiling Santa Pencils Smiling Santa Pencils
    #HLP99
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  24. Ghostly Fun Pencils Ghostly Fun Pencils
    #HLP75
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  25. Glitter USA Flag Pencils Glitter USA Flag Pencils
    #PCL669
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  26. My Little Pony Pencils My Little Pony Pencils
    #PCL648
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  27. Custom Foil Pencils Custom Foil Pencils
    #CUS854
    As low as $59.99

    144 for $59.99

    Only 42¢ each

  28. Autumn Leaves Pencils Autumn Leaves Pencils
    #HLP83
    $9.74

    50 for $9.74

    Only 19¢ each

    DISCONTINUED
  29. Scarecrow Pencils Scarecrow Pencils
    #HLP81
    $13.99

    50 for $13.99

    Only 28¢ each


  30. Spider-Man Pencils Spider-Man Pencils
    #PCL647
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  31. Disney•Pixar Cars 3 Pencils Disney•Pixar Cars 3 Pencils
    #PCL650
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  32. Disney Frozen pencils Disney Frozen pencils
    #PCL649
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  33. Spider-Man Pencils Spider-Man Pencils
    #PCL626
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each

    DISCONTINUED
  34. Pokemon Pencils Pokemon Pencils
    #PCL637
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  35. DC Justice League Pencils DC Justice League Pencils
    #PCL635
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


  36. Hot Wheels Wild Racers Pencils Hot Wheels Wild Racers Pencils
    #PCL634
    $13.99

    36 for $13.99

    Only 39¢ each


Set Descending Direction
Page
*The items above may have product safety warnings associated with them. See the item’s detail for more information.
Pencils are a budget-friendly prize that are appreciated by kids and caregivers alike. SmileMakers pencil assortments include all kids favorites including sports-themed pencils, character pencils, motivational pencils, birthday-themed pencils and more.